Be sure to snap a pic of your training and tag @WillMurtagh_DPT on social!
Deep Dive
Why Testing Your Strength Too Often Is Hurting Your Strength Gains
When you’re eager to get stronger, it’s easy to fall into the trap of constantly testing your lifts.
Early in your training, you might feel like every "tough set" is an opportunity to see what you’re capable of.
You know the days where your workout reads "Build to a tough [number of reps]".
These are exciting sessions but they can also be a trap for fr
That’s exactly what I did.
Every time the weight was supposed to be heavy, I pushed it as far as I could to try and PR.
But the reality is that constantly testing your strength doesn’t build it.
The strongest lifts I’ve ever hit didn’t come from weekly max attempts.
They came from periods of steady training with tough but manageable weights and testing periods a few times per year.
If you’re frequently testing your strength, you could be slowing your progress without realizing it.
Today I'll explain why maxing out too often can hurt your gains, why it leads to unnecessary fatigue, and how you can structure your training to build strength more effectively.
Lifting heavy weights is part of getting stronger, but there’s a difference between lifting heavy and constantly pushing to your max.
Strength training relies on progressive adaptation.
Your body needs time to recover and adapt to the loads you expose it to.
When you test your max too often, you’re forcing your body to perform at its highest capacity without giving it a chance to improve between attempts.
Your muscles, tendons, and ligaments don’t just get stronger from the weight you lift.
They get stronger from the time you spend handling sub-maximal loads with good technique.
If you're always testing rather than building, you’re missing the work that actually drives long-term strength gains.
The counterargument here is a gym like Westside Barbell who max out their lifts weekly and is one of the strongest gyms in the world.
The key difference here is that they are highly skilled lifters, they have spent years building their strength and most importantly they are extremely in tune with their top-end strength.
Thus they rarely fail and are very good at hitting a "max for the day" vs. maximal attempts to failure.
Neurological Fatigue and Its Impact on Training
Maxing out isn’t just hard on your muscles it’s incredibly demanding on your central nervous system (CNS).
Your CNS controls muscle activation, coordination, and force production.
When you lift near your max, your nervous system has to work at full capacity to generate force and maintain control.
If you’re doing this too often, your CNS doesn’t have enough time to recover.
Instead of feeling strong in your next session, you’ll feel sluggish, slow, and weaker than usual.
If you fail a heavy lift, the fatigue is even worse.
Your CNS takes a bigger hit, making it harder to perform well for the rest of the week.
Bar speed slows down, coordination suffers, and even lighter weights feel heavy.
Instead of progressing, you start to feel stuck in a cycle of subpar training.
The Skill Component of Max Attempts
Hitting a heavy single isn’t just about being strong enough to do it it requires skill.
A one-rep max is a technical lift that demands precise execution and small breakdowns in form become bigger issues.
If you're grinding through max attempts with inconsistent technique, you’re reinforcing bad habits.
Over time, this increases your risk of injury and makes it harder to hit clean, efficient lifts when it actually matters.
If you want to lift heavier weights successfully, you need to train in a way that refines your technique under manageable loads.
Maxing out too often does the opposite.
Instead of reinforcing solid movement patterns, it forces you to fight through fatigue and inefficiency.
Long-Term Consequences of Frequent Maxes
Wasted Max Physical Potential
Your ability to build strength isn’t limitless.
Most athletes reach their peak physical potential by age 30, after which the "ceiling" of their strength begins to drop.
If you’re spending your best training years constantly testing instead of building, you’re missing the window where strength gains come most easily.
​This is exactly the situation I fell prey to as a younger CrossFitter.
Frequent max attempts can bump your strength short-term but don’t contribute to long-term development.
They rob you of valuable training time that could be spent reinforcing movement patterns, improving efficiency, and gradually increasing sub-maximal loads.
By the time you realize you’ve been spinning your wheels, you may have already lost crucial years of progress.
Training smart in your prime means maximizing your potential while you still have the best opportunity to do so.
Reduced Training Longevity and Increased Injury Risk
Every heavy lift places immense stress on your joints, tendons, and connective tissues.
While your muscles may recover quickly, your joints, ligaments, and tendons take much longer to adapt.
If you push them to their limits too frequently, they’ll eventually break down.
Overuse injuries don’t happen overnight, but they accumulate over time.
If you’re constantly maxing out, small aches and pains can turn into chronic issues that limit your ability to train effectively.
Knee pain, elbow tendinitis, or nagging shoulder discomfort can derail your progress and force you to take time off.
​For me, it was frequent lower back injuries and two herniated discs that derailed my training.
The strongest athletes are the ones who train longer without setbacks like these.
How to Build Strength Properly
Know Your Numbers
If you don’t know your true one-rep max (1RM), you’re more likely to push too hard without realizing it.
Testing your max occasionally is useful, but the real benefit comes from using that data to guide your training.
Your 1RM helps you determine appropriate working weights so you can challenge yourself without overreaching.
Regulate Your Intensity
Training effectively isn’t about lifting the right weight at the right time.
Working within 75–85% of your 1RM is ideal for building strength without excessive fatigue.
These loads allow you to move efficiently while still stimulating progress.
With shorter periods of time where you approach 86-100% of your 1RM.
Reps in Reserve (how many reps are left in the tank) and Rate of Perceived Exertion (how hard you feel you're working) can also help you fine-tune your lifts.
If every set feels like an all-out grind, you’re likely training too close to failure.
Leaving 1–3 reps in the tank keeps you in the sweet spot where strength gains happen without unnecessary strain on your CNS.
Focus on Structured Progression
Strength isn’t built in a single session it’s developed over weeks, months, and years of progressive overload.
Progressing towards a max attempt should be a process.
Instead of maxing out every week, follow a progression that gradually increases intensity.
This allows you to peak at the right time without constant fatigue.
If you’re hitting near-maximal lifts too frequently, you’re likely stalling rather than building.
Give yourself time to accumulate quality reps before testing your limits.
Shift Focus From Your Maxes To Your Minimums
The strongest lifters aren’t the ones who max out the most they’re the ones who can consistently move heavy weights with confidence.
If you prioritize training with loads you can handle well, those weights will naturally increase over time.
Instead of chasing top-end numbers every session, focus on increasing the weights you know you can hit every session.
When you build a foundation of repeatable strength, your true max will rise too.
Final Thoughts on Strength Building
One of the biggest mistakes you can make in strength training is confusing frequent max attempts with real progress.
Testing your strength too often doesn’t build it long-term it simply drains your energy, stresses your nervous system, and increases injury risk.
If you’re constantly pushing to your limits, you’re missing the opportunity to develop the foundational strength that leads to long-term gains.
The most effective way to get stronger is through progressive overload, not constant testing.
Avoid the trap that I fell into as a younger lifter and now actively avoid it as I am over 30 years old.
Training within sub-maximal ranges, focusing on repeatable strength, and following a structured progression will lead to bigger lifts over time without unnecessary setbacks.
Now use this article as a guide and get to strength training more effectively!
Want a better strength-building program?
Then CLICK HEREto book a risk-free consultation to see how I can help.
This Week's Blog Post
The 5 Best Glute Exercise Machine Options In Fitness
In this guide, you’ll discover five of the best glute exercise machines that can help you achieve your fitness goals.
My flagship 1:1 program is designed to eliminate your joint pain while elevating your CrossFit performance in less than 12 weeks without overhauling your training or missing time in the gym for rehab.
​